Let's start with a quick breakdown: the credibility of a DIY project varies dramatically depending on the medium one is working with. If you are a musician or a filmmaker, a DIY project can garner instant respect, especially if it turns out well. It is the fruit of a heroic devotion to your dream. If you are a writer, but even more specifically if you are a fiction writer, self-publishing is about as respected as blatant nepotism. Read a bit more about this basic disparity (if you don't get it already) here at the Washington Post.
We've moved from calling them "vanity presses" to "self-publishing" houses. That does seem like some small forward motion. But the stigma that people who pay to publish their own books are (1) less talented writers than those who are already under the protective financial blanket of traditional houses and (2) narcissists, remains. And, due in part to the fact that most self-published titles are nonfiction, the stigma is stronger for fiction writers. (I openly acknowledge here that many self-published fiction titles are in desperate need of editing and don't bear up well under literate scrutiny. However, I also submit: the majority of websites are poorly designed and/or written. Somehow we don't dismiss the internet based on that fact.)
Another reason why the stigma is strong for fiction writers is that underneath the grand ubiquity of the big houses, there is a thriving and brilliant culture of smaller presses such as Greywolf, Akashic, and Red Hen, plus hundreds of literary magazines in which fiction writers who are "serious" about literature (i.e. hold an MFA, read current literary fiction, go to readings, teach writing, and so on) can theoretically be getting published. So self-publishing a fiction book appears to be the choice for people who have generally failed to write well enough to be chosen.
But here is an interesting fact: of the 750,000 self-published titles last year, average sales equals ten copies. Ten. There were somewhere around 300,000 traditionally published books, and it's harder to find average sales for those, but I'll put a serious amount of money on it being higher--much higher.
This disparity in sales is not simply because self-published books can't find their audience, it's because many self-published writers aren't interested in marketing. They wanted to write a book, they did it, and really they just wanted a few copies for their friends/family/coworkers. The self-published writers who are willing to commit some time and money to marketing their books end up doing very much the same thing authors at small houses do now: they schedule their own events, make their own publicity calls, send out their own books to smaller magazines for reviews, and so on. That at a small press you might have one or two marketing people serving 20 writers means that most authors who aren't getting a big push at Random House are doing a lot of the legwork on their own.
I believe traditional publishing to be a paternalistic, failing business model. What I respect and love about it is the way a team of people all work together to make a book, and to make a book available to readers. What I hate is that it is the publishers (i.e. people with financial interests at the fore) who are the arbitors of culture. With self-publishing, much like the internet, there is a theoretical democratizing of the means to cultural production. As a writer, I am no longer told by Big Daddy Publisher Man what is worth publishing and what isn't. I may be told what will be backed by marketing dollars, what will likely sell to the widest number of readers, and so on, but I have so much more room to breathe when it comes to just making BOOKS. The downside, of course, is that I am not in a close editorial relationship with someone who can help me make my novel better than it was. Oh, wait, most writers don't have that anymore either. It's only a few small presses that do any developmental editing anymore.
The advent of ebooks is another piece in the puzzle--and it is a big one, according to the Wall Street Journal. Authors have even more control in the emarketplace.
So the question I am fielding as I near the release date of A Crack in Everything, my first novel and a self-published title, is: Why would YOU choose to self-publish? The assumptions here are basic: I am an already-published writer in the early bloom of a career, I have the requisite degree, and I'm obviously serious about literary fiction, so logically I should have gone with a small press, if I couldn't get a deal at a big house.
The fact is: even the small presses are flooded with submissions, and as literary agents feel the squeeze of a shrinking traditional publishing field, they aren't taking on a lot of new authors. So let's be clear: I didn't reject any offers from small presses in favor of a self-publishing model. I didn't and don't have an agent. (Yes, I want one.) I simply decided to stop pounding the pavement for a novel that needed to get kicked out of the nest. I love A Crack in Everything for what it is, but I'm done working on it. I'm writing a new book. I'm entering a PhD program. I wanted to give Crack a body, and then turn her loose.
This is the great beauty of self-publishing, and one reason why I feel I'm part of a fiction vanguard, instead of an embarrassed band of self-righteous rejects. Publishing has already changed. Publishers are slow to catch up. Even the solidly creative, truly interesting and wonderful work coming from small presses functions in what feels to me like a rather incestuous clique of cool kids who like to print each others' stuff. I don't much blame them for this--they don't have time to vet the billion new MFA writers sending them manuscripts every day, and what they're putting out is by and large awesome. I'd love to be one of the cool kids with a punk-rock marketing plan and a Brooklyn freelancer doing my retro-chic covers. I'd love this more than I'd like to be a big-list Random House author, because of the great amount of creative freedom and teamwork that is missing at the top.
I will likely never write a piece of fiction that you can buy in an airport bookstore--mainstream fiction is not how my brain works now and I'm only getting weirder. My first novel is a kind of hybrid erotic-political-literary-twenty-something micro-bildungsroman, and the next book I'm writing is more fragmented, more academic, and has more sex in it. Maybe I'll find a home at a small press in the next few years, and maybe not. What I care about is ensuring that I am in a situation where I can make art without concern for the market, and that is nearly impossible once you've been contracted by a publisher whose main goal is profit.
This is what I celebrate most about self-publishing, small presses, ebooks, and every other force that undermines the New York hegemony: that the capitalists are less and less in charge of what is being bought, and therefore what is being written. Sure, Dan Brown will still sell millions of copies to my few hundred (or thousand, if I'm fortunate), but because of the internet I have the capability to connect directly with readers in a way that was twenty years ago nearly impossible. I know iUniverse (one of the largest self-publishing businesses, and the one I'm using) runs on a business model that emphasizes selling "services" to authors instead of selling books, but a savvy self-publishing writer can still use any one of the supported self-publishing houses for their basic book design, print-on-demand, and distribution infrastructure without becoming a victim of the company's system. In other words, we can use the tools of the capitalists to take back control of the means of production. Are most self-published books just a boring rehashing of existing cultural values? Sure. But the morphing structure of publishing offers greater opportunity for revolutionary work to take shape and become available, and that's thrilling.
Authors at traditional houses (with the exclusion, again, of many small presses) are generally left out of much of the production of a book, and give the rights to the publisher for a specified period of time--sometimes as long as the book stays in print. They are defensive players: constantly fielding attempts to change things that may or may not need changing, having to justify any problems they might have with typesetting and cover design. If they make a certain sales goal with one book and not the next, they can get dropped, even if their second book did very well. As a self-published writer, I retain copyright and could go with a different publisher at any time. I give design input that would never be allowed at a traditional house. As long as I keep my wits about what I invest, and remember not to become emotionally affected by the systemic prejudice against DIY books, I get to enter a whole new game. And in this game, I am the offensive striker, not the goalie.
Showing posts with label Writing/Publishing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Writing/Publishing. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 14, 2010
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
I Still Want to Make Books

On the recommendation of my friend and former teacher Rob Roberge (author of Drive and More than They Could Chew), I drove through the temporarily green hills of the inland empire to Cal State U. San Bernardino last week to hear the co-founder and managing editor of Red Hen Press, Kate Gale (author of Lake of Fire and quite a few others), speak about writing and publishing. Coincidentally, I had plans to have drinks with Mike Davis (City of Quartz, In Praise of Barbarians, and others), a different friend and former writing teacher, later that evening. There were a lot of people I was happy to meet, ever-so-briefly: James Brown (L.A. Diaries), Susan Straight (Highwire Moon, A Million Nightingales, more).
The context for what follows is that I'm deeply grateful for that day and those people. I've been accepted to a PhD program at UCR, am still waiting to hear from USC, and so am thinking hard about My Career and My Work and What the Hell to Do.
The very sad fact of my career these days, though, is that I can't escape the emotional importance of all those parentheses in par. 1. I can have an afternoon of taking some notes on Kate's ideas, twenty minutes of hilarious story-telling with Rob that involves some little-known facts about Jon Travolta and guacamole, I can have an evening of listening to Mike talk about his son's garage band in Dublin while he knocks back a few mojitos, I can even relax enough around Susan Straight to tell her I loved a piece she did five years ago for Salon.com about Michael Jackson. It's ridiculous to be jealous of people who've been at this business for years longer than me, but at the end of the day, I still felt humbled.
The problem isn't that I'm star-struck around Authors--I grew up around them. My dad, when he was an editor at HarperCollins (Then Harper & Row) in the 80s, used to include me and Erica in many dinners on the expense account, during which I recall moments like: a well-dressed woman with big earrings saying sweet things to me; a good-looking, funny man in a dark sportcoat stealing Maraschino cherries from my Shirley Temple. That woman was Sue Monk Kidd (who was a nonfiction writer then, but eventually the author of The Secret Life of Bees) and that man was Jim Wallis (Founder of Sojourners, author of God's Politics). We hosted authors in our home, we took them into San Francisco and walked them through Pier 39. Dad treated them special--they were the people with ideas, who needed time to work things out, who produced new and wonderful pieces of thinking and feeling, who were individuals, creatives, brilliant, all.
Some of the authors became Dad's dear friends. (I don't presume to know how many or which ones were lovers. Hey, he was a bachelor.) I loved that world of writers and books, but I loved it without any knowledge of the difficult path between writing a manuscript and getting it made into a book, really. I would see Dad reading stacks of pages, and later in the year, he'd show me the book. I knew that the editorial process was grueling at times, that it was work, but that it was also immensely gratifying and usually ended with great parties and fabulous people smiling at me.
The problem is: I didn't understand that to become an author in the first place, you had to get your pages into the hands of someone like my dad. In fact, I really didn't understand how hard that was until I started sending stories out to lit mags during my MFA. I'd already published a book of nonfiction, with Dad's help, and I'd already published a series of nonfiction articles, with both Dad and SARK's help, and publishing, consistently being published, was already something I expected for myself. The fact that literary magazines were so difficult to break into shocked me. Kate Gale drove this point home in her talk when she made it clear that the only way she ever looks at a manuscript at Red Hen is if it comes by referral. Even with some nepotism, fiction is a beast of an industry.
In contrast: my first publication was a mistake--I was at a Conari Press party with Dad, bored out of my mind (the only kid there, of course), and the hostess of the party announced that upstairs there were two computers on which party guests were invited to write brief anecdotes about times they'd received or offered acts of kindness to strangers. "We're thinking of doing a book on Random Acts of Kindness," she said, and voila! I had something to do. I went upstairs and wrote two stories, both of which were pure fiction, and didn't think about them again until one of them made it into the book. I had a crisis of conscience. I was only twelve. Conari really had no idea.
"Dad," I said, looking at the brief contract they'd sent me,"I can't let them use this story, it isn't true."
"Listen," he said. "It will inspire people, and that's the point. Something like this has probably happened to someone somewhere. It's good writing. Getting published is amazing at your age. Let them use it."
So I did.
And there's my confession, and my outing of my father's complicity. I was already writing, but I got addicted to being published at the early age of twelve. Conari's Random Acts of Kindness ended up selling like crazy, spawning sequels and bumper stickers and imitations.
So why, when I sit in a university library, listening to Kate Gale say very sensible things about how engaged a writer must be in the literary goings-on of their world, how important it is to be a "literary citizen," why does my heart sink?
Because lately, and especially since I started writing fiction, I'm bad at the publishing game.
I'm ashamed that I don't have a much, much more impressive pub list at this age, at this "level" (whatever that means), and three years after finishing my MFA. I thought I'd have an agent for my novel, I thought I'd have some longer stories in more prestigious magazines, I thought, I thought, I thought. It turns out that the world of fiction, and especially the current climate of fiction publishing, has almost nothing to do with the models of nonfiction book-making I grew up with. The privileged access I had when I was younger trained me in certain important ways: I'm calm on camera, I'm charming at a cocktail party, I'm erudite in my questions, I'm articulate in my answers, I can quip for a radio show, and so on. But it did nothing to prepare me for the actual work of writing fiction, or, the work of trying to get fiction into the world. I love writing fiction. I don't send my work out enough. I say this with a stack of stuffed envelopes next to me on the floor, because I've resolved that 2010 will be a year of Carlisle Manuscript Barrage. Tomorrow I'm sending to (the first) ten mags a short story that is, at least, weirder than the rest I've sent out. Right now it's my favorite.
Of course it is possible that I'm not getting my novel picked up, or my stories published, because I'm just not that good at writing fiction. But I'd like to suspend that judgment for now, in part so I can go on living, and in part because it's a pretty illogical conclusion until I've sent out many more stories, written a few more books, and failed more miserably for a chunk of years. There are too many smart people in my life who've encouraged me for me to get irrationally, defiantly insecure now.
Kate Gale's theory about submitting work made a lot of sense to me. She says that men are in general more consistent at the task of sending out manuscripts than women are. She thinks this is because they are trained from adolescence to deal with rejection from women. They learn to live, they learn to try again, they learn that not every girl they want is going to want them back, and that the world will go on. Women, on the other hand, rarely have to go through this kind of trial, because most of the time if they are putting themselves out there and asking someone for a date, they're likely to get affirmed. "So women take it harder," she said, "and that means we stop sending manuscripts out when the rejections start pouring in."
I looked through my Submissions Log, which I started in 2006. I was doing alright with sending things out for a while there--got a long essay published in NinthLetter, which I was proud of. Then, I had a story I loved that got rejected from seventeen magazines. Then, an essay I loved that got rejected from thirteen. Bam! After that I sent out sporadically, mostly to online magazines, or to magazines where I already knew someone. Yes, I was working on a novel during that time. But I still had shorter pieces that could have gone out, and I could have been writing new ones. I just didn't do it. What's worse: I didn't even realize I'd gotten sad about it until recently.
I studied psychology as an undergrad. I know enough to see Operant Conditioning occurring here. And that embarrasses me too, because I think I'm too smart for all that.
So. I commit, yet again, to the day-to-day business of the writer-life, in addition to the practice of actually making work. And I wish more people would talk about rejection without the "just ignore it and keep going" tough-kid act that seems to dominate these conversations.
I don't want to ignore the possibility that I might want to start my own magazine. I don't want to ignore the possibility that self-publishing, which everyone in the "legit" world still looks down upon, might be the way to build a readership before I knock on the big doors in New York again. I don't want to ignore my tendency to write work that is neither straight fiction nor strict memoir, and what that might mean. I don't want to ignore the rejections. I want to figure out how to (a) make my work even better and (b) find homes for it.
Publishing is changing. I still want to make books.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)